Critiquing and Editing Service
- Category: Critiquing and Editing Service
The North Carolina Writers’ Network offers an ongoing Critiquing and Editing Service for its members. Through this program, Network writers can have their unpublished work reviewed by established writers and editors of varying backgrounds and areas of expertise.
"It was unbelievably helpful . . . I was totally impressed, and it was well worth the price. You have a very satisfied member."
—NCWN member Reid Wilson
All manuscripts, print or electronic, must have a minimum of 5 pages.
Pages 1 - 50:
$3 per page
$2 per page
$30 for printed submission
For example, the costs to critique a 100-page manuscript would be as follows:
- All prose manuscripts—submitted electronically or in print—should be double-spaced, with 1-inch margins and in 12-point, Times New Roman font.
- Printed prose manuscripts must be single-sided.
- All poetry manuscripts—submitted electronically or in print—must be single-spaced, with a limit of only one poem per page, with 1-inch margins and in 12-point, Times New Roman font.
- Printed poetry manuscripts must be single-sided.
- Stage plays and screenplays—submitted electronically or in print—must be submitted in proper format. Guidelines for stage plays and screenplays can be found here (courtesy of Story Sense) and here (courtesy of Writopia).
- Page number and your last name should appear on each page.
- Printed manuscripts must NOT be bound when submitted, except with a paper or butterfly clip.
- Electronic manuscripts must be submitted in Word (.doc, .docx), with a file name that includes your last name & at least part of the work’s title (i.e., Wolfe_LookHomeward.docx).
- Printed manuscripts must include two cover letters: one that lists the manuscript’s title, genre, and page count, as well as your top three choices (see list below) to critique it; and another giving the critiquer a brief synopsis of the manuscript’s contents, as well as what aspects of the manuscript most concern you (i.e., plot, character development, dialogue, line editing, etc.).
- Electronic manuscripts should include the second cover letter described above, for the critiquer’s reference. This cover letter should not be included in the total page count. The information described in the first cover letter will be collected by the online registration form.
- Submit printed manuscripts, including check or money order made payable to NCWN, and SASE for return of critiqued manuscript, to:
NCWN Critiquing Service
P.O. Box 21591
Winston-Salem, NC 27120
C&ES Submission Checklist
- Your manuscript, properly formatted
- Prose: Double-spaced, 1-inch margins, 12-point Times New Roman font (single-sided if printed)
- Poetry: Single-spaced, 1-inch margins, 12-point Times New Roman font (single-sided if printed), 1 poem per page
- Play/Screenplay: See Story Sense or Writopia
- Cover letter(s) with required information (1 cover letter if electronic; 2 cover letters if printed)
- Completed online registration form, with payment by VISA, MasterCard, or Discovery, if electronic
- Payment by check or money order, made payable to NC Writers’ Network, if printed
- Self-addressed envelope (SASE) with sufficient postage to return your manuscript, if printed
The Network’s roster of critiquers is selected in accordance with the highest standards of excellence, including publication requirements and extensive mentoring and editing experience.
Karen M. Alley -- nonfiction, fiction, memoir
Karen is a graduate of Davidson College and former editor of Carolina Gardener magazine. Her writing has been published in a number of business-to-business and consumer publications, including O. Henry, Carolina Parent, Pet Age, and AAA Living magazines. With over 20 years of experience in the publishing field, Karen brings to each project a broad knowledge of the book production and design process as well as finely tuned line editing and developmental editing skills. Editing interests include literary fiction and romance, as well as memoir and non-fiction in the motivational or business genres. Visit karenalleywriting.com to learn more.
"I count myself fortunate to be an NCWN member, and doubly fortunate to have had Karen Alley edit and critique my first manuscript. Karen’s skillful and comprehensive edit, along with her strategic, cogent, and challenging but instructive criticism enabled me to say what I wanted to say—well beyond the writing in my original draft. She is a true writing coach contributing positively to every detail of composition. Karen speaks volumes to the value of NCWN membership, and I could not have asked for more."
—NCWN Member Joe Mann-Stadt
Ellyn Bache -- line editing, fiction
Bache is the author of nine novels, including Safe Passage, which was made into a movie starring Susan Sarandon; three short-story collections, including one that received the Willa Cather Fiction Prize; and dozens of short stories that appeared in literary and commercial magazines. As one of the founders of the small press, Banks Channel Books, she edited the guidebook What Locals Know about Wilmington and its Beaches and later judged and edited the winners of the Carolina Novel Award. She is past fiction editor of the literary magazines Antietam Review and Emrys Journal, and has taught fiction classes for NCWN, Emrys, and OLLI at Furman. Visit her at www.ellynbache.com.
Rebecca Bossen -- plays, screenplays
is a North Carolina-based playwright, actor, and voice and dialect coach. Her writing credits include Delilah Lee, Blue Straggler, Iced Coffee Five Cubes, The Deepest Dark, Shards of Light, and 27. Her work has been developed and performed at venues across the country, including the Source Festival, Inkwell Theatre, Chicago Dramatists, Courier 12 Collective, Burning Coal Theatre, Seed Art Share, and Sonorous Road Theatre. She is the recipient an Illinois Arts Council Fellowship Grant for Scriptworks and an Ella Fountain Pratt Emerging Artists Grant. Delilah Lee was named an O’Neill National Playwrights Conference finalist. She is a proud member of the Dramatists Guild of America, Inc. www.rebeccabossen.com.
Gregg Cusick -- flash fiction, short fiction, longer fiction
Gregg Cusick holds a Master’s in English/Creative Writing from NCSU, where he also taught English Composition and Literature. His story collection, My Father Moves Through Time Like a Dirigible, was published by Livingston Press in 2014, and his stories have appeared in over two dozen journals and won numerous awards, including The Lorian Hemingway Short Story Competition and The Florida Review Editor’s Prize. He has been a freelance editor with Carolina Academic Press and for the past nine years a judge for the Raleigh Fine Arts Society student fiction contests. Additionally, he has been a literacy tutor for the past thirteen years. Gregg believes strongly that every piece of writing is important, valuable, and also improvable. His aim is to help writers tap the heart of their fiction/memoir, and to help make each piece the best possible, truest to the writer’s vision.
Golda Fried -- fiction, screenplays
Golda Fried taught creative writing and English composition at Guilford Technical Community College for more than ten years, and now teaches English at Central Piedmont Community College in Charlotte. She is the author of one collection of short stories, Darkness then a Blown Kiss, and one coming-of-age novel, Nellcott Is My Darling, which she recently adapted into a screenplay with a co-writer. Nellcott is My Darling was nominated for the Governor General’s Literary Award in her native Canada. She has a BA in Film and Communications from McGill and a Masters in Creative Writing from Concordia University. Website: www.goldafried.com.
Eric Glawe -- screenplays
Eric Glawe is a graduate of the UCLA's Department of Theater, Film, and Television with his MFA in Screenwriting. During his time at UCLA, Eric was able to learn from great screen and television writers such as Ana Lily Amirpour (A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night, The Bad Batch), Jill Goldsmith (NYPD Blue, Ally McBeal, Law and Order and Boston Legal), Charles Holland (JAG, The Quad, Black Lightning), Linda Voorhees (Lion King II: Simba’s Pride), Lew Hunter (Fallen Angel, Otherworld), and recently retired department chair Richard Walter. In addition, Eric was chosen to work with Francis Ford Coppola, assisting on his project, Distant Vision. He learned from producing great Joe Roth (The Sixth Sense, Maleficent, Alice in Wonderland) and was an intern at Warner Bros. with Berlanti Productions (Arrow, Flash, Riverdale, Love, Simon). His produced projects include an adaptation of Romeo and Juliet titled Romeo and Julio, a short film screened at UCLA and TV Pilot Salem High which is being submitted to producers along with Eric’s screenplay on the life of Disney artist Mary Blair entitled Small World. Eric teaches Screenwriting and Film Studies at Winthrop University in Rock Hill, SC, and is represented by William Pettit Agency out of Atlanta.
Kathy Goodkin -- poetry
Kathy Goodkin is the author of poetry collections Crybaby Bridge, winner of the Moon City Poetry Award (Moon City Press, forthcoming), and Sleep Paralysis (dancing girl press, 2017). She also serves as an editor for Gazing Grain Press. Her poems and criticism appear widely in journals such as Field, Denver Quarterly, Cream City Review, Redivider, The Volta, and elsewhere. She holds an MFA in Creative Writing from George Mason University, where she served as Editor-In-Chief for the literary magazine Phoebe: A Journal of Literature and Art. In 2011, she was the recipient of the Academy of American Poets Joseph A. Lohman III Poetry Prize. She has taught creative writing, literature, and composition in a wide range of community and academic settings, including universities, community colleges, and maximum security prisons. Her editing experience includes literary and scholarly journals and presses. Find her online at www.kathygoodkin.com.
Linda Hobson -- fiction, nonfiction
Hobson, the author of a book on novelist Walker Percy and editor of a second, has a Ph.D in English from the University of Alabama and is a graduate of both Denison and Duke. She is at present an editor and book reviewer. Hobson has edited many published works of fiction, nonfiction, and poetry as well as taught writing to adults and to secondary- and university-level students. Her literary interests are American fiction and nonfiction and English/British literature.
"I’ve never been edited as thoroughly and with as much consideration as Linda (Hobson) showed toward my story. Her micro edits were precise, and her macro edits found things inside the story that even I didn’t realize were there. She wrote all over every page—an incredible amount of work for what turned out to be a very reasonable fee....I found her edits and critique to be spot-on: demanding more from me as a writer, while also engaging with the story so completely that I felt like she was really invested in its eventual success. That’s the very definition of a great editor, isn’t it?"
—Anonymous NCWN member
"In searching for the right person to critique and edit my manuscript, I studied what was written about each of the persons NCWN has listed. The Anonymous NCWN member’s excellent and concise description of how Linda Hobson edited that member’s work was the reason Dr. Hobson was my first choice. Well, now I can verify that member’s description and add to it. Considering all my efforts in studying how to write my novel, I consider Dr. Hobson’s editing as the best of any course, class, or book, and certainly the most encouraging. And, yes is the answer to the member’s question, 'That’s the very definition of a great editor, isn’t it?' By the way, my book is on the market."
—Darryl DuBose, NCWN member and author of Passion, Shadows, and Time
Virginia Holman -- narrative nonfiction, memoir, fiction
Author, essayist, magazine writer, and writing instructor Virginia Holman has more than twenty-five years of experience as a teaching writer. Her memoir of her mother’s untreated schizophrenia, Rescuing Patty Hearst, was a Barnes & Noble Discover Great New Authors Selection, and received the Outstanding Literature Award from the National Alliance on Mental Illness. She’s served as the Kenan Visiting Writer at UNC-Chapel Hill, the writer-in-residence at Duke University Medical Center, and taught workshops in creative nonfiction for more than a decade in the MFA and BFA writing program at UNC-Wilmington. She's published essays and articles in DoubleTake Magazine, Redbook, Prevention, Self, O Magazine, More, The Washington Post, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, and elsewhere. Her work has been reprinted in Pushcart Prize series, broadcast on This American Life, and she's received fellowships and awards from the North Carolina Arts Council and The Carter Center. She has written a monthly column for Salt Magazine in Wilmington since 2013. “Please note: I don’t do deep line editing or copy-editing. I am encouraging, direct, and I can pinpoint where long-form stories aren’t functioning at full capacity. I work with my authors to come up with individualized recommendations and strategies to help them refocus and proceed.”
Susan Stafford Kelly -- line editing, fiction, personal essay, humor (Note: Susan Stafford Kelly critiques only printed submissions)
Susan Stafford Kelly attended UNC-CH, holds a Master of Fine Arts from Warren Wilson College, and has taught creative writing at Salem College, UNCG, and for the NCWN. Her novel, How Close We Come, won the Carolina Novel Award, was reissued nationally by Warner Books, was an Alternate Selection in Book-of-the-Month Club, and was published in Russian and German. Warner Books published her second novel, Even Now. Pegasus Books published her successive novels The Last of Something, Now You Know, and By Accident, which won the Sir Walter Raleigh Award. Susan writes everything from obituaries to speeches, and is a frequent contributor to Our State magazine, as well as O. Henry, Pine Straw, and Salt magazines.
Stephen Kirk -- fiction, nonfiction
Stephen Kirk edited over 200 books in a wide variety of fiction and nonfiction categories during his tenure at John F. Blair, Publisher, including multiple winners of prizes including the Sir Walter Raleigh Award, the Foreword Reviews Book of the Year, the Independent Publisher Book (IPPY) Award, the Benjamin Franklin Award, the Storytelling World Award, the National Outdoor Book Award, and the Parents’ Choice Award. He is the author of Voices from the Outer Banks, Scribblers: Stalking the Authors of Appalachia, and First in Flight: The Wright Brothers in North Carolina and has been reprinted in the Best American Short Stories series.
Steven Manchester -- line editing, fiction
Steven Manchester is the author of the #1 bestsellers Twelve Months, The Rockin' Chair, Pressed Pennies, and Gooseberry Island; the national bestsellers, Ashes, The Changing Season, and Three Shoeboxes; the multi-award winning novel, Goodnight Brian; and the beloved holiday podcast drama, The Thursday Night Club. His work has appeared on NBC's Today Show, CBS's The Early Show, CNN's American Morning and BET's Nightly News. Three of Steven's short stories were selected "101 Best" for Chicken Soup for the Soul series. He is a multi-produced playwright, as well as the winner of the 2017 Los Angeles Book Festival and the 2018 New York Book Festival. He is also an accomplished speaker and currently teaches the popular workshops, "Publish: See Your Work In Print and Writing Fiction that Sells." As a professional editor, he provides line-by-line editing for spelling, punctuation, grammar, and sentence structure, as well as critical commentary on plot, character development, scene setting, and dialogue. As a well-published author, Manchester understands the polish needed to approach potential agents and publishers and will review cover letters and synopses. He has also written The Author's Toolbox, assisting other writers in their quest to be published. See: www.stevenmanchester.com
"I have been working on my novel for quite some time and really wondered if I was on the right track. Therefore, I decided it would be most helpful to send a few pages just to see what someone thought about it. I must say, I am really glad I did, as Mr. Manchester's words greatly inspired me to continue on."
—NCWN member Jennifer Bower
Ruth Moose -- fiction, poetry (Note: Ruth Moose critiques only printed submissions)
Moose has published stories in The Atlantic, Alaska Quarterly Review, North American Review, and other places. She taught creative writing at UNC-Chapel Hill for fifteen years. After she retired, she published two novels, Doing It at the Dixie Dew and Wedding Bell Blues, which won the Malice Domestic prize from St. Martin's Press. She has also published six books of poetry, including The Librarian and Other Poems. She is the author of the short-story collection Going to Graceland. She lives in Pittsboro.
Elizabeth Oliver -- flash fiction, short fiction, nonfiction, line editing
Oliver is the founding managing editor of The Rambler, a national literary magazine. She has extensive experience critiquing and editing across genres, from flash fiction to long memoir pieces. She is passionate about the preservation of personal voice in stories and has worked with writers with a variety of experience, from beginners to accomplished authors. Oliver holds a BA in journalism and an MFA in creative writing; her work has appeared in various publications and the flash fiction anthology Long Story Short (UNC Press).
Alice Osborn -- speculative fiction, fiction, memoir, poetry
Alice Osborn’s past educational and work experience is unusually varied, and it now feeds her work as a singer-songwriter, educator, and book editor. In the past fourteen years, Alice has taught thousands of aspiring fiction, poetry, and memoir authors, and songwriters of nearly all ages both around the corner and across continents. Heroes without Capes is her most recent collection of poetry. Previous poetry collections are After the Steaming Stops and Unfinished Projects. Alice is the recipient of a United Arts Council of Raleigh and Wake County 2019 Professional Development Grant, a Roads and Let's Talk About It Scholar for the NC Humanities Council, the artist-in-residence for the Western Wake Farmers' Market, and is a senior docent at the NC Museum of History. A former editor for Wake Living magazine, Alice is also the editor of the anthologies Tattoos and Creatures of Habitat, both from Main Street Rag. The President of the NC Songwriters’ Co-op, a member of the boards of both the NC Writers’ Network and NC Museum of History Docents, and a Pushcart Prize nominee, she’s currently working on a novel and CD about the ill-fated Donner Party. She also plays old-time fiddle, mandolin, electric bass, and bluegrass banjo. Alice lives in Raleigh with her husband, two children, and four birds all named after musicians. Visit Alice's website and blog at www.aliceosborn.com and check out her music at www.reverbnation.com/aliceosborn.
A.D. Reed -- nonfiction, fiction
A.D. Reed (www.myowneditor.com) has been a professional writer and editor for more than thirty years, in journalism, commercial writing, and book editing and publishing, best known as the author of Reed’s Homophones: A Comprehensive Book of Sound-alike Words, now in its fourth edition. Prior to returning to NC in 1993, he worked as a writer, copywriter, and marketing executive with NBC Television in New York while moonlighting as a freelance editor for ArtNews & Antiques World Books. He began editing full-time in the 1990s. He has edited Asheville’s monthly Urban News (www.theurbannews.com) since its founding in 2005, previously wrote a regular column for The Asheville Citizen-Times, and edited its monthly neighborhood edition, West Asheville News. His editing work includes two nonfiction volumes by Prof. Mallory McDuff of Warren Wilson College, and the Revolutionary War study Swords in Their Hands: George Washington and the Newburgh Conspiracy, by Dave Richards, scheduled to be added to the curriculum at West Point in 2020. He also edited and published the acclaimed novel Trang Sen by Sarah-Ann Smith; RF Wilson’s Rick Ryder Mystery series; two memoirs by Robin Russell Gaiser, Musical Morphine and Open for Lunch; several books of children’s literature; and five collections of poetry. He is the founder and owner of Pisgah Press in Asheville and its poetry imprint, ArsPoetica.
Dawn Reno Langley -- line editing, fiction, nonfiction
Dawn Reno Langley is a Fulbright scholar (Pakistan) with an MFA in Fiction from Vermont College, and a Ph.D in Interdisciplinary Studies from The Union Institute and University. She began her career in journalism, writing and editing for such magazines and newspapers as Vermont Woman, USAir Magazine, Better Homes and Gardens, and dozens more. She has managed, edited, or written for literary journals such as howl!, The Hyco Review, The Green Mountains Review, The Oklahoma Review, Burrow Press, the Provo Canyon Review, and many others. Her published books include children’s books, YA novels, nonfiction books on art and antiques, and novels, including her most recent, a National Book Award nominee titled The Mourning Parade. Finally, she has taught writing at many levels, from Montessori grammar school kids to graduate level university, and in several countries. Reno Langley offers developmental editing on literary and academic texts, as well as line editing on most other written works.
Amy Rogers --fiction and nonfiction
Amy Rogers was a founder and the Publisher of Novello Festival Press, the award-winning independent press that put more than 300 writers into print since its founding in 2000. Rogers’ books include Hungry for Home: Stories of Food from Across the Carolinas and Red Pepper Fudge and Blue Ribbon Biscuits. Her work was included in Cornbread Nation 1: The Best of Southern Food Writing. Rogers is a frequent food and culture commentator for NPR station WFAE. Her work has appeared in numerous publications, including the design magazine American Bungalow, the literary magazine the Oxford American, and the Charlotte Observer. She has been Writer in Residence at the Wildacres Center and a program presenter at dozens of events, festivals, arts centers, schools, and other venues.
"Amy Rogers framed the feedback in a way that left me inspired to improve my novel. She provided excellent overall critiques and within the manuscript highlighted specific things I’d done well and need to do more often as well as repeated errors that I need to be aware of. I’m very pleased with the cost and quality of editing though the NC Writer’s Network. Thank you all for providing this service."
—NCWN member Heather Brewer
Debra Simon -- line editing, nonfiction, fiction
Debra Simon, editor and publisher of Carolina Woman magazine, has worked with hundreds of novelists, playwrights, essayists, and journalists to polish their writing. While interning at The Wall Street Journal, Simon researched and wrote daily articles as well as three front-page stories. She served as a New York-based reporter for Reuters, a copy editor for the Hartford Courant, and an assistant business editor for the Miami Herald. Following her move to North Carolina, Simon struck out on her own, creating Lean Times, a regional wellness magazine. Later, during a year-long backpacking trip around the world, she developed the idea for Carolina Woman. Launched in 1993, the magazine has a readership of 100,000. One of its most popular features is the annual writing contest. As a freelancer, Simon has contributed to publications ranging from Businessweek and Advertising Age to Seventeen magazine.
Robert Wallace -- fiction, nonfiction, line editing
Robert Wallace has received an Emerging Artist grant from the Durham Arts Council, a Writer’s Fellowship from the NC Arts Council, and has been a Blumenthal reader. He has had fiction and nonfiction published in various journals and newspapers, including Bryant Literary Review, NC Literary Review, Proximity, Cagibi, International Journal of Comparative Literature and Translation Studies, Aethlon, O. Henry Festival Stories, and The News & Observer in Raleigh. He is a two-time winner of the Doris Betts Fiction Prize. His work also has been in several anthologies, including Racing Home: New Short Stories by Award Winning North Carolina Writers. He is the author of the novel A Hold on Time.
Tamra Wilson -- fiction, nonfiction
Wilson is a graduate of the University of Missouri School of Journalism and earned her MFA at Stonecoast. She has been a fellow at the Virginia Center for Creative Arts, a Blumenthal reader, and the recipient of two artist project grants funded by the NC Arts Council. She is co-editor of Idol Talk: Women Writers on the Teenage Infatuations that Changed Their Lives (McFarland). All but two of twenty-one stories in her collection Dining with Robert Redford were previously published in such journals as The MacGuffin, Emrys Journal, Epiphany, and North Carolina Literary Review. She has written three first-place entries in the Charlotte Writers' Club Children’s Story Contest and won the Jesse Stuart Prize for Young Adult Fiction in 2009. She is a Road Scholar for the NC Humanities Council with special interest in Southern fiction and child narrators, and for years has written a slice-of-life column for her local newspaper.